|
List Names, p
washingtonpost.com
Hello
Change Preferences | Sign Out
Sign In | Register Now
The Washington Post
Print Edition | Subscribe
News
Politics Business Education Real Estate
Nation Technology KidsPost Obituaries
World Entertainment Religion Corrections
Metro Health Post Magazine Archives
Opinions
Columns & Blogs Feedback
Cartoons & Videos Outlook
Editorials Message Boards
Sports
Redskins D.C. United NBA MLB
Nationals Capitals Local Colleges Golf
Wizards Orioles High Schools World Cup
Arts & Living
Style Movies Travel Dating Horoscopes
City Guide Television Music Home & Garden Comics
Entertainment News Food & Dining Museums Books Crosswords
Ad: Click here for Travel Specials & Deals
Discussions
Thursday, July 6, All Times ET
Ken Lay's Death, 11 Home Front, 11 Today's Schedule
Post Politics, 11 Potomac Confidential, 12 Weekly Schedule
Dotcom Era, 12 Color of Money, 12 Transcripts
Photos & Video
Photos: Shuttle Discovery Day in Photos
Video: Justin's Got Game News Video
Video: Prisoners and Soldiers Documentary Video
City Guide
Search D.C.-area events and locations.
Find movies, restaurants, bars and clubs.
Classifieds
Merchandise Pets Death Notices
Personals Rentals Local Shopping
Jobs
Find a Job Post a Job
News & Advice Employer Login
Cars
Buy a Car Experts & Advice Dealer Specials
Sell a Car Coupons
Real Estate
Real Estate: Buy | Sell | Recent Sales | Directory
Rentals: Find a Rental | Rent Your Place | Directory
Shopping Deals
SEARCH:
News
Powered by Google
| Search Archives
washingtonpost.com > Columns
Print This Article
E-Mail This Article
RSS News Feeds
Top News
What is RSS? | All RSS Feeds
today in slate
Arts & Life
Slate
Why Can't We All Just Get Along?
Reading the Humane Society of the United States' suggestions for how to prepare your pet fo... More
Tilting at Windmills
By Anne Applebaum
Wednesday, April 19, 2006; Page A17
"Look there, friend Sancho Panza, where thirty or more monstrous giants rise up, all of whom I mean to engage in battle and slay, and with whose spoils we shall begin to make our fortunes."
-- from "Don Quixote" by Miguel de Cervantes
Wind turbines on farmland near Wasco, Ore.
Wind turbines on farmland near Wasco, Ore. (By Don Ryan -- Associated Press)
Stem Cells and Morality
» Robert P. George and Eric Cohen | Stem cell advances can come from scientific ingenuity, not unethical cloning experiments. Congress should insist on it.
* Broder: The Court Hands Congress an Opportunity
* Taking Exception: No Platitudes for D.C. Schools
* PostGlobal: Ideas for Solving the Gaza Impasse
OPINIONS SECTION: Toles, Editorials
Save & Share
* Tag This Article
Saving options
1. Save to description:
Headline (required)
Byline
2. Save to notes (255 character max):
Blurb
3. Tag This Article
To my eye, they are lovely: Graceful, delicate, white against green grass and a blue sky. Last summer my children and I stopped specially to watch a group of them, wheels turning in the breeze.
But to those who dislike them, the modern wind turbine is worse than ugly. It is an aesthetic blight, a source of noise pollution, a murderer of birds and bats. As for the still-young wind industry, it is "an environmental plunderer, with its hirelings and parasites using a few truths and the politics of wishful thinking to frame a house of lies." Far from being clean and green, "corporate wind is yet another extraction industry relying on false promises," a "poster child for irresponsible development."
Such attacks -- those come from http://www.stopillwind.org/ , the Web site of Maryland anti-wind activist Jon Boone -- are not atypical. Similar language turns up on http://www.windwatch.org/ , on http://www.windstop.org/ , and on a dozen other anti-wind sites, most started by local groups opposed to a particular project. Their recent, rapid proliferation is not an accident: After languishing for years on the eco-fringe, wind energy has suddenly become mainstream. High oil prices, natural gas shortages, better technology, fear of global warming, state renewable-energy mandates and, yes, tax breaks have finally made wind farms commercially viable as well as clean. Traditional utility companies want to build them -- and thus the traditional environmental movement (which supports wind energy) has produced a handful of untraditional splinter groups that are trying to stop them.
They may succeed. Already, activists and real estate developers have stalled projects across Pennsylvania, West Virginia and New York. In Western Maryland, a proposal to build wind turbines alongside a coal mine, on a heavily logged mountaintop next to a transmission line, has just been nixed by state officials who called it too environmentally damaging. Along the coast of Nantucket, Mass. -- the only sufficiently shallow spot on the New England coast -- a coalition of anti-wind groups and summer homeowners, among them the Kennedy family, also seems set to block Cape Wind, a planned offshore wind farm. Their well-funded lobbying last month won them the attentions of Rep. Don Young (R-Alaska), who, though normally an advocate of a state's right to its own resources, has made an exception for Massachusetts and helped pass an amendment designed to kill the project altogether.
The groups do have some arguments, ranging from the aesthetic -- if you are bothered by the sight of wind turbines on a mountaintop, which I am not (or, anyway, not when compared with the sight of a strip mine) -- to the economic. They are right to note that wind will not soon replace coal or gas, that wind isn't always as effective as supporters claim, and that some people are going to make a lot of money out of it (though some people make a lot of money out of coal, and indeed Nantucket summer homes as well).
But they also reflect a deeper American malady. The problem plaguing new energy developments is no longer NIMBYism, the "Not-In-My-Back-Yard" movement. The problem now, as one wind-power executive puts it, is BANANAism: "Build Absolutely Nothing Anywhere Near Anything." The anti-wind brigade, fierce though it is, pales beside the opposition to liquid natural gas terminals, and would fade entirely beside the mass movement that will oppose a new nuclear power plant. Indeed, the founders of Cape Wind say they embarked on the project in part because public antipathy prevents most other utility investments in New England.
Still, energy projects don't even have to be viable to spark opposition: Already, there are activists gearing up to fight the nascent biofuel industry, on the grounds that fields of switch grass or cornstalks needed to produce ethanol will replace rainforests and bucolic country landscapes. Soon the nonexistent "hydrogen economy" will doubtless be under attack as well. There's a lot of earnest, even bipartisan talk nowadays about the need for clean, emissions-free energy. But are we really ready, politically, to build any new energy sources at all?
applebaumanne@yahoo.com
Print This Article
E-Mail This Article
RSS Feed
Post a Comment
Comments: (Limit 5,000 characters)
Comments that include profanity or personal attacks or other inappropriate comments or material will be removed from the site. Additionally, entries that are unsigned or contain "signatures" by someone other than the actual author will be removed. Finally, we will take steps to block users who violate any of our posting standards, terms of use or privacy policies or any other policies governing this site. Please review the full rules governing commentaries and discussions. You are fully responsible for the content that you post.
© 2006 The Washington Post Company
Featured Advertiser Links
Refinance Rates As Low As 2.9% - FREE QUOTES!
$200,000 loan for $917/mo. Bad credit OK
For College Graduates, Reduce Your Student Loans
Barbra Streisand Tickets, Tim McGraw Tickets w/ Faith Hill, NASCAR Tickets, Eric Clapton Tickets
ReNu, Celexa, Car Accident, Vioxx, Bextra
$145,000 Mortgage for Under $484/Month!
Promotional Pens, T-shirts, Custom Hats
Cool Gadgets, Great Deals, Visit CircuitCity.com
SEARCH:
News
Web
Powered by Google
NEWS | OPINIONS | SPORTS | ARTS & LIVING Discussions | Photos & Video | City Guide CLASSIFIEDS | JOBS | CARS | REAL ESTATE
washingtonpost.com: Help | Contact Us | About Us | Advertise With Us | Site Index | Site Map | Make Us Your Homepage | mywashingtonpost.com | Work at washingtonpost.com
The Washington Post: Subscribe | Subscriber Services | Advertise | Electronic Edition | Online Photo Store | The Washington Post Store | About The Post | National Weekly
The Washington Post Company: Information and Other Post Co. Websites
© Copyright 1996- The Washington Post Company | User Agreement and Privacy Policy | Rights and Permissions
|
